Note: I wrote this back in July, apparently put it away for some additional editing, then proceeded to completely forget about it for five months. December isn’t exactly golf season, but c’est la vie. For purposes of clarity, this isn’t intended to be a sports blog. I’m not entirely sure what it is intended to be – guess we’ll have to wait and see…
It’s so easy to take our good fortune for granted, to assume that we are divinely entitled to whatever valuable attributes we possess. Sometimes a worst-case scenario has to come along to jar us out of that vain reverie.
Golfer Michelle Wie is currently providing us with a graphic and pitiful object lesson to that effect. For those of you who are not sports fans, Ms. Wie is an athlete of extraordinary physical gifts who was capable of playing championship-level golf in her early teens. What has happened since that time makes one’s stomach turn.
Rather than make a normal progression through the ranks of women’s amateur golf, Michelle’s parents persuaded her to turn pro while still in high school. Even though she had the physical skills to be competitive at the top level of women’s pro golf, and finished well in some early events, it soon became clear that she lacked the judgment and mental toughness to win. This wasn’t surprising – winning in golf has always been at least as much about the mind as the body, and Michelle had not been given an opportunity to learn how to perform and win under intense pressure against opponents who possessed rock-hard resolve.
That decision was bad enough, but it’s been horribly, woefully compounded by the parents’ unfathomable insistence that the girl needed to play – and continue playing – in men’s pro events before she’s ever won a single tournament in women’s pro competition. “Success” in this case would be defined by merely making the cut, and she has only managed to accomplish that small feat one time, in a minor event in Japan. Insisting on continuing to play in men’s events at this point in her stunningly unsuccessful career is a gross insult to everyone involved with the LPGA tour, at a time when she ought to be focusing on earning the respect of her fellow competitors. Michelle has now turned 18 – it’s time for her to start taking responsibility for her own decisions and recent events don’t offer much hope in that regard. In trying to come back from a wrist injury, first she was disqualified from a minor women’s tournament for one of the most egregious sins a professional golfer can make – leaving the scoring tent without first signing her scorecard. Then comes the announcement that she will accept yet another sponsor’s exemption to play in another minor PGA event.
It’s like watching a completely unnecessary slow-motion train wreck. Tiger Woods, who is almost certainly destined to become the greatest golfer of all-time, paid his dues and played college golf, participating in and winning numerous amateur competitions before turning pro. Apparently Michelle Wie’s parents were convinced that stooping to such non-superhuman activities was unnecessary for their daughter. It’s now entirely unclear whether Michelle – this prodigy of immense physical talent – will ever win a single professional tournament of any kind.
This isn’t a story about golf, or sports in general, so much as it is a cautionary tale for our species. After all these millenia of human civilization, hubris continues to fell the mighty.